Marketing & Media

Connecting Through Credibility: How to Leverage Influencer Marketing 

Elyse Ruback, Content Director

Influencer doing podcast

Influencer marketing used to feel a bit like the Wild West—unpredictable, flashy and full of filters. It was the land of celebrity selfies, hashtag overload and questionable ROI. Well saddle up, partner. Things have changed. 

What Is Influencer Marketing? 

It’s a strategy where brands partner with individuals who have built an engaged audience to promote products or services. 

Today, it’s less about celebrity status and more about trust. Influencer marketing is strategic, measurable and increasingly one of the most effective ways to connect with real people in authentic, relatable ways. 

Still wondering, “Does influencer marketing work?” Consider this your friendly nudge. In a world where attention is hard to earn—and even harder to keep—credibility is your brand’s secret weapon. And influencers? They’re holding the mic. 

Influencers: Not Just for Gen Z (But Also, Definitely for Gen Z) 

Let’s talk numbers. 

  • More than 86% of U.S. marketers plan to partner with influencers in 2025. Why? Because it works.
  • Influencer campaigns deliver, on average, $6.50 in ROI for every $1 spent—and that’s just the baseline. Influencers offer the kind of personal connection traditional ads just can’t replicate.
  • In 2024, nearly seven in ten Gen Z shoppers discovered new products through social media. But it’s not just about younger consumers. A growing number of Gen X and even Baby Boomers follow niche creators for product recommendations, lifestyle content and local expertise.

Influencer marketing is no longer about viral stunts or perfectly filtered posts—it’s about relevance. And that relevance is paying off.

So, Who Counts as an Influencer?

An influencer is anyone who has built a loyal following and can inspire action or shape opinions—whether they have 1,000 followers or 1 million. Forget Hollywood A-listers. Today’s influencers are content creators, niche experts, educators, entertainers and everyday people who’ve earned trust in specific communities.

They might be a local fitness coach sharing wellness tips on Instagram, a tech enthusiast reviewing gadgets on YouTube, a mom with a relatable parenting journey on TikTok or a podcast host whose audience hangs on every recommendation. What do they have in common? Influence—rooted in authenticity, credibility and connection.

What Is Micro-Influencer Marketing?

Contrary to popular belief, bigger isn’t always better. While mega-influencers might get you exposure, micro-influencers (think 10K–50K followers) often drive more meaningful engagement. Their followers tend to be more loyal and more likely to take action.

Micro-influencers come in different flavors, including niche bloggers, local community leaders and platform-native creators. The real magic? Their audiences trust them. That trust is currency—and your brand can borrow some of it.

Where Influence Happens: Social Media Influencers

Choosing the right platform is just as important as choosing the right partner. Social media platforms like TikTok might be the new search engine for Gen Z, but Instagram, YouTube and even LinkedIn have vibrant influencer ecosystems, too.

The key is alignment.

  • If your brand is all about thoughtful insight and business leadership, a LinkedIn micro-influencer might be your perfect match.
  • Selling lifestyle or health products? Instagram influencers and TikTok creators could give you both reach and relatability.
  • Want to stay hyper-local? Consider partnering with community voices—like local chefs, fitness instructors or educators—who’ve earned real-world clout.

Some influencers operate offline but have equally persuasive power in their networks—think PTA presidents, community organizers or well-known local personalities.

How to Work with Influencers

Before you dive into DMs or sign a contract, do your due diligence. Look beyond follower counts and focus on authentic indicators, like strong engagement and meaningful comments—signs that the influencer has earned real trust with their audience. And please, don’t let a big follower count blind you. Bots are real. Bought followers are still a thing. A “popular” account with no meaningful interaction is a red flag. If the comments on every post are vague (“Love this!” “So true!”), those probably aren’t real fans.

Take time to understand your potential partner’s brand and values. Influencer marketing is a two-way street. The content they create reflects you, and you’re putting your name alongside theirs.

The Long Game in Influencer Brand Collaborations

Influencer marketing isn’t just a campaign tactic—it’s a relationship. The best results often come from long-term partnerships that evolve with your brand. If your influencer becomes a true ambassador, their audience starts to see your brand as a natural extension of their trusted content.

And if it doesn’t work out? That’s OK. Communicate clearly, exit gracefully and take what you’ve learned into your next collaboration.

Proceed with Caution (But Don’t Be Paralyzed)

No strategy is without risk. There are occasional stumbles—think PewDiePie’s fallout with Disney—but most issues can be prevented with smart contracts, brand safety guidelines and a solid vetting process.

Remember: You’re not just looking for a mouthpiece; you’re building a partnership with someone who influences opinions, behaviors and purchasing decisions. Treat them as such.

Bottom Line: Why Influencer Marketing Works

When built on trust and authenticity, influencer marketing can deliver real, measurable results—far beyond vanity metrics.

  • It reaches the right people in the right way.
  • It earns credibility in ways that traditional ads can’t.
  • It works across generations and platforms.
  • And it scales—from micro-budgets to major brand moments.

Ready to put influencer marketing into practice?
Download EVR’s Digital Big Book to access proven strategies, tools and step-by-step guidance—from setting smart goals and choosing the right creators to measuring real results. It is your complete roadmap to building campaigns that connect, convert and scale. Need help finding the right fit, building a campaign or simply figuring out where to begin? Let’s connect.

Recent Posts

Looking for more?

Sign-up to join our email list and be among the first to receive industry insights from the experts you trust.

    Stay in touch